With reporting by Hannah Saunders
The new RapidRide G stretching 2.5 miles along Madison Street from the waterfront to Madison Valley via First Hill and Capitol Hill is unprecedented in the city’s rollout of a growing alphabet of “bus rapid transit” lines. The first days of service across the line’s special coaches, dedicated lanes, center loading passenger islands, and coordinated signaling has been an illustration in the challenges of doing new things in the big city.
Starting with Saturday’s launch, the promise of 6-minute service and smooth rides through the corridor has mostly been out of reach due to early hiccups around signal and signage coordination, collisions, and delays due to mechanical failures and operator challenges with the new coaches.
King County Metro says it is responding to early issues though it also referred some questions about signalling to the Seattle Department of Transportation.
UPDATE: “This is the first RapidRide line with six-minute headways and, as we expected, our operators continue to gain experience with our scheduled operations and maneuvering with the varying traffic conditions along the route,” a Metro spokesperson said in a statement
Metro calls the line’s start a success despite the issues and says it is working with SDOT to address the signal priority issues.
Metro says the new or upgraded signals along the route along with a special signal at the terminal to ensure buses start their routes smoothly will continue to be adjusted.
“Metro and SDOT staff are working to resolve any issues as they come up,” the spokesperson said. “SDOT is currently updating signal timings along Madison Street and at the intersection with Martin Luther King Jr Way. SDOT will keep monitoring and adjusting these signals to improve traffic flow for both buses and general traffic in the coming weeks.”
The full statement from Metro appears at the end of this post.
Other issues also have added up in the growing pains around the newly launched $144 million line that includes bus service 10 new stations between 1st Ave and MLK Jr Way operating from 5:00 AM to 4:00 AM daily with a bus every six minutes between 6 AM and 7 PM Monday through Saturday.
The growing RapidRide system’s arrival on Madison is hoped to optimize an area that was already served by a tangle of Metro routes in neighborhoods unlikely to be connected to Sound Transit’s light rail network anytime soon.
Some issues are small in comparison to the ambitions of the new line. One Rapid G Line bus driver with a year of experience under their belt, for example, told CHS the protocol on the new route requires they switch drivers every time at the end of the route — just one of the many new steps and procedures slowing performance on the new line during the launch.
“It could be worse,” the driver said.
The driver sat at the wheel of one of the 13 new hybrid electric coaches Metro purchased specially for the route. Their three doors on the right, two on the left layout is designed to help speed loading with RapidRide G’s selection of center islands along the First Hill stretch of the line. New bus smell wafted through the vehicle.
The area is expected to continue to be a center of Seattle population and job growth as well as the city’s core for hospitals and medical services.
The opening day bus was packed with passengers throughout the route with riders waiting to hop on at each stop along the way. The RapidRide G coaches mostly utilize a dedicated lane until the special markings end near the 22nd Ave stop, forcing the driver to merge into a jumpway.
At this stop, a man loaded on the bus and complained to the driver about waiting 30 minutes for the bus on the very first day.
The RapidRide G coaches follow their own signal lights along the route: a white horizontal line means the driver must stop, while a vertical white line means the driver can go.
The launch brought some major signalling screw-ups with the city. At 5th and Madison, the bus hit a light right before stopping and others cars received priority. The RapidRide G bus waited through five rounds of lights.
“This is why all the buses are late,” the driver said.
The schedules were cleaner for the reorganization of Metro’s routes around the new RapidRide core that includes changes and cuts to dozens of bus lines including moving Route 10 back onto E Pine. The new dedication of Route 3 to serving the neighborhoods around Summit Ave had all of the excitement of the G rollout without the logistical headaches.
On RapidRide G, there are other major inefficiencies that need to be worked out. RapidRide G bus drivers cannot click a button to open the doors when reaching stops, but rather have to “kiss the curb” with the wheels of the bus, the driver said. The coaches have sensors that register when the doors should open, which the driver said is a safety feature. In case of emergencies, there are two manual emergency door releases that the driver can pull.
UPDATE: Metro says a mechanical failure on one of its coaches involving the curb system is being addressed. “Our Vehicle Maintenance team are still investigating the issue with the single RapidRide G Line bus that experienced what appears to be a temporary mechanical issue on Saturday,” a spokesperson said. “Vehicle Maintenance is reviewing what happened prior to apparent failure of the equipment so it can be addressed if it continues.”
Later, another rider hopped on and said they had waited for 15 minutes to catch the bus though the digital signs at the stop had reported a bus was due in five minutes. Like many, the rider said they were forgiving since this it was the first day of the line and that there would be hiccups.
That patience won’t last long — or people will quickly learn to ignore the information signs. Sound Transit is still struggling with real-time information signage through years of light rail service in the city.
Other types of signage on the RapidRide G line might need work. Some of the most useful informational signage posted at stops was on temporary printouts posted to provide information to riders about how best to load onto the new coaches including vital information for riders utilizing accessibility features and bike riders. The signs helped riders know you can’t, for example, load a bike on the front rack of a G bus from a center island. There’s a special part inside the coach for bikes and their riders. Signs like that would be useful long after the temporary signage fades away or is torn down.
Metro is also trying to boost the business communities along the route, promoting nearby shops and venues to the new G riders. In addition to transforming the corridor’s transit, biking, walking, and driving safety elements — and lots and lots of paint — RapidRide G work included millions of dollars of attached utility and infrastructure work by the city that created years of major challenges for businesses and residents living along Madison.
Back on RapidRide G, the bus driver has a small monitor that shows how many feet until the bus reaches the next stop, and the time in minutes on how far the bus is running behind. After reaching 1st Ave, the bus for this ride was about 40 minutes behind due to previous delays — including a car being parked in the bus lane.
Later Saturday, a slew of RapidRide G busses were held up with none arriving on time and without electronic bus stop signs displaying these changes. One Metro worker told CHS there was an accident on 1st Ave and that they were running special buses to resume Rapid G Line services. Thirty minutes later, no new buses had arrived.
UPDATE: Here is the full statement from Metro on the launch updates.
The launch of the RapidRide G Line has been very successful with hundreds of trips operated each day and carrying thousands of riders since launching. This is the first RapidRide line with six-minute headways and, as we expected, our operators continue to gain experience with our scheduled operations and maneuvering with the varying traffic conditions along the route.
Our Vehicle Maintenance team are still investigating the issue with the single RapidRide G Line bus that experienced what appears to be a temporary mechanical issue on Saturday. Vehicle Maintenance is reviewing what happened prior to apparent failure of the equipment so it can be addressed if it continues.
The boarding instructions for the center islands along the RapidRide G Line are designed to be temporary and last four weeks. The expectation is that much like Seattle Streetcars, as riders become used to boarding and exiting the buses from the platform, the instructions will not be needed.
Like any first week of service change, buses experienced some delays and bunching.
Our Service Quality team is in contact with our operators to help them navigate the issues as they come up. This includes additional supervisors to dispatch coaches and to mitigate any delays. Field Supervisors are helping solve minor mechanical issues that may arise, and an additional operator is being assigned to help get our operators breaks if the schedule does run behind.
Prior to the launch of service on Sept. 14, SDOT improved signal priority for the RapidRide G Line by installing new or upgraded signals along the route. These changes help buses bypass traffic and switch lanes more easily. There is also a special signal at the terminal to ensure buses start their routes smoothly.
Metro and SDOT staff are working to resolve any issues as they come up. SDOT is currently updating signal timings along Madison Street and at the intersection with Martin Luther King Jr Way. SDOT will keep monitoring and adjusting these signals to improve traffic flow for both buses and general traffic in the coming weeks.
Our focus during this period of adjustments to signaling, traffic, and operators on the RapidRide G Line will always be on ensuring that our riders are receiving the service headways that we said will be part of this new route.
$5 A MONTH TO HELP KEEP CHS PAYWALL-FREE THIS SPRING
🌈🐣🌼🌷🌱🌳🌾🍀🍃🦔🐇🐝🐑🌞🌻
Subscribe to CHS to help us hire writers and photographers to cover the neighborhood. CHS is a pay what you can community news site with no required sign-in or paywall. To stay that way, we need you.
Become a subscriber to help us cover the neighborhood for $5 a month -- or choose your level of support 👍
Part of Madison is concrete and other parts are asphalt with no apparent rhyme or reason. A couple of the island stations have steel plates surrounded by asphalt. Not a great look.
It’s been a mess the whole project. We overlook the stop by Swedish. We’ve seen them pour then rip up concrete in that area 3 times over the course of the project.
Those steel plates were place three days before the route opened up (and after they did all that painting effort) on the 14th when they started digging furiously in the evening.
The wear and tear differential between the cement and asphalt sections are going to be a problem in the future.
I have to add that, although the buses were on schedule, the 10 and 11 bus drivers were definitely experiencing a large amount of people that weren’t aware of the reroutes. I was on the 10 roundtrip downtown and back Saturday and people kept calling out to the driver when they realized they weren’t going where the passenger was expecting to go. The drivers were patient and kept explaining but you could see that they were getting tired of dealing with angry people.
I rode a #11 bus yesterday afternoon where the driver himself seemed to be unsure what the route was, because he asked the passengers for advice about a certain turn. The passengers, it turned out, did not all agree whether they were currently riding the #10, #11, or #12 route, and differing answers were given.
That happens on new routes. Often the riders know and the drivers do not. New routes and new drivers to routes.
I lived in Skagit county. So the routes are pretty intricate. Lots of people spread out over large areas and not anywhere near our population. New drivers would miss a turn and the whole bus says “Take the next left!” So they can go back and turn around w/o a hassle. Busses are huge and the streets are skinny in those little HWY 20 towns east and west. Lots of tree branches smacking the bus for a couple blocks…lol
So yeah, that’s actually normal. It’ll get better. This is actually par for the course. Also? It’s way harder to do on paper due to all the variables.
I just ride my scooter for now. Wait till it gets smoothed out. It’s pretty sweet.
Shoulda done central streetcar lanes with a removal of all car traffic lanes coupled with a pedestrianization of Madison by widening sidewalks and replacing asphalt with green space.
Private car traffic and public transit should never mix!!
Madison is a major arterial. In principle I agree with your idea of not mixing car traffic and public transit (and bike lanes too!) but we have to think of Seattle as a pre-existing city, not as a “new” place. There’s no comparable arterial to move all the existing traffic that’s on Madison, unfortunately.
lol people think we need to prioritize cars over everything.
Gee, maybe that’s because the vast majority of Seattle moves by automobile?
True in the more suburban towns. But here downtown we don’t own that many cars. Per capita we are high on the list for pupils transportation usage. So the Madison project serves a crazy amount of people and is worth every penny.
Well, they are the ones paying to get all of these people off the road so that they can drive faster.
Anyone who doesn’t like it, could walk.
See: Third avenue boomer
SDOT messed up signal priority? Shocking.
Then there is the First Hill street car where the signals are not giving the trolley priority so it gets all the ride lights with the cars.
Really? C’mon…Try making it work on paper vs. real life.
You sketch it out. Get it refined. Apply it. Fix the kinks.
It’s engineering. Not guess work.
If those sensor-opened doors don’t end up working 100% of the time in every case for years, drivers don’t even have the option to open them manually?
Typical example of how poor the planners are for our transit systems. Emergency manual exits will not deal with loading/unloading mass riders when it fails more times than “they” could have imagined. Exhausting watching this happen over and over and over…Think thrice, act once anyone?
Rapid Ride G is a posterchild for why I’m voting NO on Proposition #1. Rapid Ride G is a massively wasteful boondoggle of specialized equipment — the driver can’t open the entry doors!!!! — route-specific rolling stock!!!! For voter-levies from now on: projects not packages.
Did you vote again Obamacare because the website had glitches? I know who you’d vote for.
We have a D- infrastructure grade. Flat wages 40+ years.
I am thinking all of the wages being raised and infrastructure projects have been completely ignored because a certain group. The largest, most active voters in American history is the exact reason we are so far behind.
So your “let em’ eat cake” attitude is unsurprising. A completely out of touch view. You don’t know what it’s like. You’ll never use transit. Yet here you are? Wow…A typical.
“Voter Levees” are schools too yunno? Are you starting to see what you and your generations done to all of us?
What a terrible statement from Metro. This launch is “very successful”!? So we should expect these types of issues to happen every time? Or we should even be happy things aren’t worse?! Its hard to have trust in these public agencies
I am puzzled about the reported policy of drivers switching buses each time they get to the Madison Valley terminal. I’m not sure if one round trip will give a driver a sense of any malfunction to be written up. Those thirteen
million dollar buses sound as if they have been over-engineered with some
extra bells and whistles. We’ll all stay tuned, eh?
Over an hour to get from point A to point B on the “rapid” G in what used to take 12 minutes
This project seems more anti-car than pro mass transit.
A lot of people take Madison to get to the highway to get out of the city not to go downtown so the line is useless for them
Not so. It is intended to make the average bus trip along the route three to four minutes faster. Truly transformative!
The ones most critical are the ones who’ll never use it.
This is about their money and making excuses to cover up that one fact. All the excuses are camo.
The Westbound car traffic from 17th to 12th is totally fubared now. There was a backup for 3 blocks at almost 10pm on a Sunday night. You can almost walk faster. They need to figure out light timings. Something is totally borked. During the day I’ve seen cars backed up from 12th to 16th… Past the bus lane switcheroo and blocking the bus lane as a result.
I’m glad for the G line. It’s cheaper than a scooter and almost as fast. It’s way cheaper than parking. But not everything is an appropriate business trip.
Route 2 inbound trips will be stuck in that queue. The intended pathway was not yet open on Tuesday