Post navigation

Prev: (05/08/23) | Next: (05/09/23)

With one of the first mass-timber highrise apartment buildings in the United States about to open, researchers test how wood will stand up to a major Capitol Hill earthquake

The Heartwood under construction. It opens for residents soon at 14th and Union. (Image: Timberlab)

(Image: Nheri ESEC)

The eight-story Heartwood is ready to open above E Union as the first one of the first mass-timber highrise apartment building in the United States. Tuesday, University of Washington researchers will conduct a test simulating a major earthquake on Capitol Hill and how a life-size, larger version of a ten-story, cross-laminated timber building holds up to the shaking of “The Big One.”

CORRECTION: The Ascent in Milwaukee opened in July 2022.

You can watch the test live and see how the building holds up — or doesn’t.

“Mass timber is a new material, so we are testing it in a taller building as a proof of concept and to study if this is actually feasible — there aren’t any buildings in the world that are 10 stories and have structural systems made entirely of timber,” UW Civil & Environmental Engineering Ph.D. student Sarah Wichman said in the university’s announcement about the project.

Unlike the Heartwood which is being readied to open soon for residents at 14th and Union, the test building the UW students are jostling using a giant shake table facility at the University of California San Diego is timber all the way down to its seismic bracing. At Heartwood, the team from DCI Engineers used steel lateral bracing and a concrete foundation to steady the first of its kind building.

But there is evidence that the “ductility” of wood could also help make timber buildings safer during earthquakes. “This means that it is a material that supports a great deal of deformation until the moment of its fracture,” ArchDaily reports. “That is, it bends before breaking.”

The city’s more standard housing stock, meanwhile, will also face a test in a major earthquake. Since 2001’s large Nisqually quake, many of the city’s buildings have been reinforced like the Piston and Ring preservation-friendly overhaul on 12th. Here’s a look at how Capitol Hill’s greatest old buildings stand up, with elegance, to earthquakes. But a 2012 survey effort by the city showed Capitol Hill is home to one of the largest clusters of unreinforced masonry buildings in the city.

The city has yet to implement requirements it has been working on for years to mandate quake readiness projects for unreinforced masonry buildings in Seattle. Still, some property owners have moved forward with reinforcement projects as the mandate work continues. In 2013, the city told CHS 14% of all buildings designated as URM structures were undergoing voluntary retrofits. Nearly 20% of Seattle’s unreinforced masonry structures were on Capitol Hill, First Hill, and in the Central District.

The results of the monthlong Natural Hazards Engineering Research Infrastructure (NHERI) Tall Wood project-funded test could help usher in more mass timber construction and help make the projects even more sustainable. UW says the researchers are evaluating the performance of two primary types of mass timber, Cross Laminated Timber and Mass Plywood Panels, “which are relatively new to the building scene and are slowly gaining popularity as a greener alternative.”

The UW report notes the environmental concerns at the core of the move to explore mass timber construction — the production of concrete is a huge contributor to global carbon dioxide (CO2) emissions. Mass timber has other benefits including local sourcing — all of Heartwood’s components, for example, were sourced within a 400-mile radius of the Seattle job site, its developers say.

In San Diego, the test of the more fully timber-based construction will bring some unknowns but the researchers think their designs should hold up to the special shake sessions planned for Tuesday. The researchers say the building they will be testing was “designed to be located in the heart of Seattle — the Capitol Hill neighborhood.”

“Seattle was selected due to the city’s risk of significant, yet uncommon, seismic events,” the researchers asure.

A previous test of a two-story timber building in 2017 which wasn’t location-specific was deemed a success.

During the monthlong testing process including Tuesday, a series of earthquakes are being simulated with increasing intensity. The final phase will include ground motions for the maximum earthquakes that buildings are designed for in Seattle, which has two primary faults: The Seattle Fault that runs east-west through the middle of the city, capable of earthquakes up to 7.4 magnitude, and the Cascadia Subduction Zone along the coast, capable of a magnitude 9 earthquake.

CHS reported here in 2021 as the construction permit was issued for the Heartwood. The Community Roots Housing and DCI Engineers project will open soon as affordable workforce housing.  As a Type IV-C permitted project, it was allowed to climb to eight stories and have full exposure of its timber beams so residents and visitors can see, touch, and feel the wood. Other types can build higher — like this project on First Hill — but require that the wood be kept more “encapsulated” the taller the building. And, yes, the Heartwood’s steel bracing and concrete foundation will also be in place.

You can learn more about leasing options on the soon to open building at heartwoodseattle.com.

 

HELP KEEP CHS PAYWALL-FREE
Subscribe to CHS to help us hire writers and photographers to cover the neighborhood. CHS is a pay what you can community news site with no required sign-in or paywall. To stay that way, we need you.

Become a subscriber to help us cover the neighborhood for as little as $5 a month

 
Subscribe and support CHS Contributors -- $1/$5/$10 per month

19 Comments
Inline Feedbacks
View all comments
d4l3d
d4l3d
1 year ago

Concrete is a major CO2 contributor and resource depleter. Forests are one of our major carbon sinks and a resource that can’t keep up with demand as a renewable. How is this not just a move sideways? This is such small thinking within a grotesquely diminishing time frame.

PleaseExplain
PleaseExplain
1 year ago
Reply to  d4l3d

What should we build dense housing out of then?

Please spell "formaldehyde"
Please spell "formaldehyde"
1 year ago

The building will need to be torn down within the next 15 years.

Monitoring for formaldehyde, which is only one of the gasses anyone living there should be concerned with, will turn out to be too high for long term exposure. Measuring air quality has become cheap enough for just about anyone to afford.

The first patent for manufactured lumber was handed out in the 1920’s; none of this particularly new.

Concerns about off-gassing? Entirely known.

Sensors that allow just about anyone measure these sorts of gasses outside of a laboratory? Those are new.

LeonT
LeonT
1 year ago

Earthquake hell, how will it stand up to a fire?

Derek
Derek
1 year ago
Reply to  LeonT

Concrete causes the fires that burn up forestgs.

Mars Saxman
Mars Saxman
1 year ago
Reply to  LeonT

The IBC has been updated to specify design safety features for mass timber buildings:

https://www.fireengineering.com/fire-prevention-protection/tall-mass-timber-buildings-and-fire-service-concerns/

Matt
Matt
1 year ago
Reply to  LeonT

Mass timber is very common in Japan, so not sure where you’re getting that it’s earthquake hell…

cellbell
cellbell
1 year ago

My understanding is that high-rise steel buildings have less noise issues for apartment dwellers than low-rise wood-framed buildings. Will the steel bracing on this project help with that? Sustainability should certainly be a goal but there also needs to be exploration of making this housing a more pleasant living experience on a daily level.

Derek
Derek
1 year ago
Reply to  cellbell

Headphones work. I think this is such an overblown issue because people really are entitled about noise. Karen neighbors told me to turn down my volume 2 blue tooth speaker outside the other day near Summit and Roy. Just a joke.

Emma
Emma
1 year ago
Reply to  Derek

Hey Derek, headphones work. Why do people feel the need to broadcast their music in public when headphones work?!

Caphiller
Caphiller
1 year ago
Reply to  Derek

You’re the one who should be wearing headphones. Playing music on a speaker outside is obnoxious and they were right to tell you to turn it off.

FHRes
FHRes
1 year ago
Reply to  Derek

I was blaring some music while someone was trying to sleep and this Karen asked me to turn it down.

Matt
Matt
1 year ago
Reply to  cellbell

I would think more generally that metal would transfer sounds better than wood… It probably has much more to do with design than material

Spccc
Spccc
1 year ago

The Ascent in Milwaukee is a 25 story mass timber apartment building that opened over a year ago, so how is this the first mass timber tower in the US?

Mike
Mike
1 year ago
Matt
Matt
1 year ago
Reply to  Mike

This is true, not sure if the headline is just updated or if they originally said “one of the first”… Either way, really cool to see 😀 My brother works at the forest products laboratory in Madison that did some work on the Milwaukee building, and I’ve toured some of their own facilities. Really cool to see work with some more natural and renewable materials.

Matt
Matt
1 year ago
Reply to  jseattle

No worries at all, that’s how good journalism works! I particularly appreciate the general use of strikethrough text by this site for these types of minor updates.